Episode 53: 6 Reasons Communications Leaders Still Do It All (And Shouldn't)
Your doctor doesn’t do everything. Your CFO doesn’t do everything. So why are Communications leaders still taking on everything themselves?
As Communications has become more specialized, the expectation that one person should know how to do everything hasn’t gone away. From strategic counsel to hands-on execution, Communications professionals are often expected to take on work that belongs to multiple specialties, and sometimes work that doesn’t belong in Communications at all.
In this solo episode of the Communications Business Advisor™ Podcast, Tara McDonagh explores six reasons Communications leaders continue to accept these expectations, even when it limits their influence and authority, stretches them beyond their capacity, and reinforces misunderstandings about the profession.
Drawing on her own experience as a corporate Communications leader, Tara shares what happens when responsibility outpaces authority, why even experienced professionals struggle to push back, and how Communications teams can begin resetting expectations.
She also introduces a concept borrowed from healthcare: operating at the top of your license. It’s a different way to think about how Communications leaders and their teams use their expertise, allocate responsibilities, and build greater authority within the business.
In this episode, you’ll learn:
- The six reasons leaders continue doing it all, from external pressure and curiosity to conflict avoidance and limited authority.
- Why Communications professionals accept expectations that don’t reflect the more advanced, specialized expertise of the field.
- How reporting structures and decision-making authority influence what lands on Communications teams.
- Why being capable of doing something doesn’t necessarily mean it’s the best use of your expertise.
- An example from an earlier stage of Tara’s career where she did work well beyond her scope of expertise at the time, and why
- Why gaining influence and authority is essential to changing expectations.
About Tara McDonagh
Tara McDonagh is a Communications Business Advisor™ activist, founder of Tara McDonagh Communications, Inc., and Founder of Raise the Tide® for women in Communications. She advises Chief Communications Officers, Vice Presidents, and Senior Directors at Fortune 500 and other large organizations on advancing their function as critical business advisors. Recognized by the Public Relations Society of America (PRSA) in 2026 as an industry champion and thought leader, Tara helps Communications teams elevate their reputations as critical advisors while elevating our profession and the people in it.
Tara McDonagh Communications’ clients span industries including healthcare, pharmaceuticals, life sciences, automotive, manufacturing, food and beverage, financial services, and higher education. Tara McDonagh’s clients typically range from about $1 billion to more than $180 billion in annual revenue and from about 2,000 to more than 150,000 employees.
With nearly 30 years of experience leading communications at some of the nation’s largest, most complex, and most highly regulated brands, Tara’s counsel comes from experience across communications disciplines: public relations, public affairs, internal communications, executive communications, and crisis communications. She quite literally knows what it’s like to do the role and helps those she advises elevate their team’s expertise and their own reputations.
Resources mentioned
Communications Team Authority Index™
Wondering where your team stands in its journey toward greater authority? Take the free Communications Team Authority Index™ to assess your team’s current position.
Explore the Communications Team Authority Index™
Communications Business Advisor™ Team Intensive
Learn how Tara works with Communications teams to clarify responsibilities, navigate real-world challenges, and develop a shared approach to advising the business.
Learn more about working with Tara
Episode 42: When Helpfulness Becomes a Career Ceiling
Tara references this earlier episode when discussing the helper trap and how being helpful can limit a Communications professional’s growth.
Browse the Communications Business Advisor™ Podcast
Stay connected
Explore more insights and resources at Tara McDonagh Communications.
Subscribe to Level Up: Be Extra for insights on elevating your work and your team’s reputation as critical business advisors.
For women in Communications, explore Raise the Tide® and join the Raise the Tide® email list for additional resources and updates.
If this episode resonated with you, please consider rating or reviewing the podcast. It helps more Communications professionals discover these conversations.
Until next time, keep advising. Always keep advising.
Help Elevate the Profession
Share this episode with your colleagues and communications network.
Episode Transcript
Edited for readability. Speaker dialogue and substantive discussion are preserved.
Episode 53: 6 Reasons Communications Leaders Still Do It All (And Shouldn’t)
Thanks for coming along with me today on this journey as we continuously advance as Communications Business Advisors™, ’cause we never graduate from this, right? We’re always evolving.
When Specialization Becomes the Norm
So I am going to start today’s episode with a question: Who out there has time for doctor’s appointments? You have to be retired to take care of them. I mean, there are so many. Come along with me on this journey. I swear there’s a point here. The past two weeks, I have been on a mission to get all of my checkup appointments taken care of, and by taken care of, I mean scheduled, because, you know, it can take like eight, nine months to get in to some…
see some specialists, and it is a whole thing, let me tell you. I went to my PCP two weeks ago, which some of you might call them your general practitioner. I went to my dermatologist this week. I have an allergist appointment in a few weeks because finally I figured out that maybe I’m sick every spring because of allergies, not because I’m sick, which allergy testing seems to align with that, so I’m onto a new appointment with a new specialist.
Can’t wait to meet the allergist. My mammogram is scheduled, but not until the new year because it takes a while to get in. I went for bloodwork this morning, so we’ll see what that has to say. What’s going on with that? I don’t know. We’ll see. Hopefully it’s all good. I have another appointment to schedule because the hormone replacement therapy I’m on for perimenopause needs some adjustments.
Shout out to all of my women friends out there. I still have three more specialists to get to. And oh, by the way, don’t forget the dentist appointments. Plus, I really have to get the flu shot for me and my daughter, ideally before Thanksgiving. And on that note, my daughter, I have one. I can’t imagine you people that have multiple children handling all of this stuff.
God knew better than I did when I was given one child. Anyway, add another set of appointments for her, right? The number of doctor’s appointments that I have just for myself as a relatively healthy human is wild. Add in my kiddo, and it just feels like it’s going to be my new response to my therapist when she asks me what my hobby is, which, by the way, is maybe my least favorite question of all time.
My hobby is scheduling and attending doctor’s appointments. That’s what my hobby is. So here’s the point. Here’s the thing about all of this, right? I’m getting there. Not quite there yet, but keep coming with me on this journey. Over time, this has become normal. There was a time in my, like, grandparents’, probably more like great-grandparents’ day, when people were just going to see the town doctor, who was the only person who could figure out what was going on with us and how to manage it, and we typically only saw the doctor when we were sick.
I mean, old school me, like, I’m… Okay, well, maybe not old school me, old me, like those of you who grew up in the ’80s can come along with me on this. I picture Doc from Little House on the Prairie. Now, these changes I’m talking about here, they happened in the 20th century, so I’m not talking about quite as long ago as Little House on the Prairie times.
But the point is, our expectations changed, and they changed because medicine got more and more specialized. It got better. We started seeing doctors before things became problems. And it feels like my PCP, or what some of you might call a general practitioner, and what back in the Laura Ingalls’s Little House on the Prairie days, what they called just Doc, that person is an expert in triage these days.
They decide what specialists need to weigh in on different things. My general practitioner, my PCP, she doesn’t really treat me. She’s great, but she doesn’t treat me. Even when I’m sick, I’m not seeing my PCP. I’m seeing a nurse practitioner or a physician assistant. And I know this is standard for everyone out there, seeing different physicians for different things or different healthcare providers, seeing practitioners who aren’t your general practitioner, aren’t your, you know, standard go-to doctor, seeing them only maybe once a year.
Why Is Communications Different?
That’s standard. It’s just how things are done now. So here’s my question: Why do we expect this in healthcare, but we wouldn’t even dream of it in communications? And I’m not talking about sending people to, like, 12 different places or 12 different things, or making them have 12 different specialists and 12 different doctor’s appointments.
I’m talking about even the internal management of the communication Why does it seem so normal to recognize that our general practitioner won’t know how to handle most medical issues, but can send us to a specialist, and yet it’s not at all normal in communications to do that within our own departments?
We wouldn’t even think about doing that. We just figure it out ourselves. Most of you won’t like my answer to this, but you know me, I’m committed to tell it to you straight. I always will. I’m going to tell you the truth. So get ready. It happens because we allow it. For the most part, it’s because we allow it, and we allow it for a few reasons, and I’m going to get into that today.
1. We’re Told Doing Everything Is Normal
The first one is we’re gaslit into thinking it’s normal. Someone tells us we, quote-unquote, “should” know how to do something because we’re communications, and we then assume they’re right because they come at us with such clear confidence, right? Sometimes the task or the request, it’s… I mean, request veiled as a command, it’s comms related.
Sometimes it’s not even comms related at all, but we get gaslit, and we keep going on with it. I have some wild stories on this front. We probably all do. It sounds a little bit like this. “Uh, yeah, so can you create those company values in the next, like, two or three days and then share them with the executive team for our feedback?”
Uh, I’m sorry, what? But they say it with such confidence. We’re like, “Uh, am I supposed to know how to do this? Is this part of scope? Is this part of, like, what I’m supposed to be doing? Is this how it’s done?” The answer is no, it’s not how it’s done, but they come at us with such confidence, we get gaslit, and we just go with it.
2. We Undervalue Our Own Expertise
Now, number two, we don’t value our profession as a profession enough. Not really. Not truly. And I know some of you are ready to fight me on this one, but give me a hot second here. Have some patience with me. As much as many of you are upset about not being brought in early enough or not having enough staff or reasonable budget, and by the way, budget is something we’re going to talk about real soon, you don’t advocate for it the same way that you advocate for the right thing for the business when it comes to a comms approach or something critical.
At least not all of you do. A lot of you don’t. And deep down, deep, deep down, it’s because some of you think that what you do is too basic, too simple, maybe too logical. You value and respect finance’s insight and their tracking. You value IT’s software development, and you think that what they do is hard.
It requires expertise. What you’re not seeing, though, is that what you do, it’s also hard. It also requires expertise. It’s just that there are some around you constantly telling you it’s easy in subtle or overt ways, oversimplifying it. They see maybe one-tenth of what you do at best, and so they think that they could do it, too.
Enter the gaslighting I mentioned from my first point, and this just compounds here. I have huge respect for the finance and legal and IT departments that I’ve worked with over the years. The partners who have valued and respected me, some shared that they couldn’t do what I do. One told me that I was the most underpaid and undervalued executive in the company.
She said that I was an absolute steal for the company and the benefits that I returned for the investment that they were paying. Which was exactly what I needed to hear to go change that and get more money, by the way. But these strong advocates, the ones who point out our expertise and advocate for us, they aren’t the norm.
You never really know what you’ll get in this field where that’s concerned. It’s maybe a third split with our peers and other functions and how they view us. One-third deeply respect us, and they lift us up. Thank you. Shout out to all of you. One-third just don’t really interact or focus or care about what the heck we’re doing, and one-third, they think that they could do our jobs easily.
They undermine us. They make us feel like we’re less than. Face this last third enough over and over, and it will shake anyone’s confidence. It will shake anyone’s belief that they are worth it, that their function is worth it. It’s not your fault, but it is something you need to be aware of and something that you can shift.
3. We Love a Challenge
Third, we are naturally curious people in this field. If you have gotten far enough in this field where you’re listening to this podcast, then I will tell you that I 100% am on board with you believing and thinking and acting as a curious human. We in this profession, we love a challenge and an opportunity to learn something new and different.
Tell someone in this field to master something new, and we are on it. We’re on it, which is how we became the equivalent of PCPs and surgeons and dermatologists and endocrinologists and radiologists and every other specialist under the sun in one human and in one job.
4. We Defer to Senior Leaders
Four, even when we’re maybe more senior in our age, we’re still often the youngest person at the table.
We’re expected to advise more senior leaders constantly, sometimes two or three levels above us. We’re just getting credibility for ourselves and for our function, and in some cases, reassurance for ourselves that we do in fact belong at that big table. Anybody who enters into this world of being at that executive table is all thinking to themselves, “Am I doing it right?
Is this good enough?” And you’re no different. Everyone goes through that. The difference is that you’re almost always the youngest person at the table. So when someone tells us we should do something comms related, and sometimes not comms related at all, especially if they’re more senior to us, especially if they’re an executive, we defer to them.
They’re more senior. They’ve been around longer. They must know, right? At least that’s what we think at first. It’s similar to that experience that we’ve all had of being in the critical meeting and stopping ourselves from saying the very obvious thing out loud, the thing that we saw and no one else did.
The first time we’re in that room, we don’t say it. We don’t say the obvious thing out loud. Then someone else finally speaks up, and they’re treated like the Messiah. We’ve all seen this. You know, “What a brilliant point, Brian. I wonder why we didn’t catch this before. So great that you caught that.” That’s when we kick ourselves, and we finally get it.
They aren’t smarter. They aren’t. They’re more senior. They happen to be more valued. They’re not smarter, and they’re not better. We’ve experienced that ourselves. So then why are we still deferring on subject matter that is clearly about our expertise more than anyone else’s? Why? Okay then, on to the fifth reason why we allow ourselves to be and do all things when it comes to communications rather than resetting expectations that there are different specific areas of expertise that we need to call upon within our field.
5. We’re Afraid of Conflict
Here it is. Five, we’re afraid of conflict. We don’t know how to address it without making enemies, being perceived as difficult, or how to redirect successfully. And we for sure do not want to be the department of no. That is our worst nightmare. We see that happen to the reputations of peer functions all the time.
I mean, I have seen it over and over and over again with marketing Those peer functions that get that department of no reputation, everyone hates them. By the way, some of them are deserving reputations. But when we see this, we sure as heck aren’t going to let that happen to us. And this, by the way, is where the helper trap comes in.
If you want to dig into that one, go back to listen to episode 42, When Helpfulness Becomes a Career Ceiling.
6. We Don’t Have the Authority
Six, and finally, the one that we all point to the most, which is valid We don’t have authority. If you’re not in a centralized communications function, the person who holds our salary in their budget gets to decide what our job is.
I mean, ultimately, ultimately they do. And what they say, we have to do. When they say it’s ours, it’s ours, whether it belongs there or not. I have a story on this one. I’m going to share with you all the human world of Tara, the mistakes that I made, the things I learned along the way, how I would do things differently.
When Responsibility Outpaces Authority
I was a manager-level in a communications role inside a company, and the senior leader who was funding my salary told me to develop a part of an earnings-related script for one of our major divisions. I was his go-to personal comms expert, doing everything from PR to internal to executive comms for the division.
I was doing it alone, at least at first. And when he asked me to develop this earnings story, I was entirely outside of my depth. I had never done anything like that before. I did the things that I mentioned earlier in this podcast episode as a result. I wondered if I was supposed to know how to do this.
I asked someone else in our field if I was supposed to know how to do this. I asked a peer in another division about what they would do, and finally I pushed back. Unsuccessfully, I will add, but I did push back. Now, that senior leader that I worked with was… He was not having it. He gave me part pep talk about my skill set that he deeply believed in and part hammer about doing what I was told.
We had a really good working relationship, and he was a big advocate of mine, so I was going to just figure it out, as uncomfortable as it was for me. So I figured it out. I interviewed different business leaders in the division. I became besties with a finance partner who talked me through the numbers and what was meaningful to ask about from her lens, you know, uh, what to ask the other leaders.
I wasn’t responsible for the numbers, so, like, don’t freak out there, but I was responsible for telling the story behind the numbers, what led us to those results, you know, beyond thinking about it from the perspective of a press release. And I became really good at it. Prepping for that part of the call script for that line of the business became a normal task, but not many people knew that that’s what I was responsible for.
As a result, though, I became really, really strong at understanding the ins and outs of the business. I’m glad that I did it in retrospect, but I figured some things out along the way, too, looking back at all of the signals. In that job, comms, which equaled me, at least until I successfully advocated for staff, was the dumping ground for certain work because I didn’t have the authority to say no.
In the case of this earnings story, it took me a while to see it clearly, but the senior leader asking me for this work was making the ask of me because he wasn’t close enough to know the reasons behind the numbers, and he didn’t want anyone else knowing that If he really knew those numbers, if he knew all the reasons, he could have handled it in a half-hour call with the person who pulled the final script together.
And there’s stories behind this part and how I know that, but he just didn’t know the reasons behind the numbers, so he sent me to find them first and used, quote-unquote, storytelling and pulling the threads together into a narrative as the reasoning for why I was doing it. I did work that was not my responsibility because the senior leader who had my salary in his budget decided it was my responsibility, and I sure as heck wasn’t paid at a level that would dictate that kind of work.
I was punching at least two levels above my grade level when I was doing that work. It was work that belonged also in someone else’s area, in investor relations area, but it landed with me because I was the one who would go find the answers, and I didn’t have the authority to say no. There were other components to it, like I was being a helper.
I wanted to do good things for the business. I cared about making sure that leader looked good. That leader believed in me, so I wanted to reciprocate. Of course, he believed in me, and he also dumped on me. Both were true. But I wanted to be helpful, to be an asset. I wanted to learn more. But most importantly, the thing I think about these days is that I didn’t have authority to say no.
So when people say reporting structure doesn’t matter, I have to believe they’ve never been informed they’re responsible for something that is wildly outside comms expertise but have to do it anyway because that leader owns their salary, their performance evaluation, and any hope of promotion to anything else ever.
In this case, I reported to the business leader. I didn’t have a comms leader that I could go to, so it was really his call. People pleasing becomes the name of the game in this, and that is the thing that can harm us most in this field: lack of authority. Was it my fault I didn’t have authority? Is it your fault that you don’t have authority if you don’t know?
Was it my responsibility to push back? Yes. Was it also realistic that I had to do the thing anyway when he said no firmly? Also yes. That was a couple decades ago, but not as much has changed in this area related to authority. The reality is still the same. Someone else holding budget and decisions and authority over an area of expertise that you own and they have no concept of Now, since that experience, I made it my mission to gain authority for my function, to gain authority for communications, and I did at that company and others.
Now I teach others how to do it too, and it is hard. It is not simple. It’s definitely not simple if you don’t have the structure and the leaders that just know it and have it right from the jump, but it is possible to get more influence and authority without those things. It’s a path that you don’t just leapfrog to, but continuous progress.
It is possible. Continuous advancement along that, like, continuum to becoming a more authoritative advisor. I’ve done it. I help others do it now too.
Operating at the Top of Your License
Okay, we’re back, and I want to leave you with an analogy that might be helpful. Since we started out the episode talking about healthcare and all of my doctor’s appointments, I’ll continue along with that analogy. There’s this concept in healthcare called operating at the top of your license.
It means that if you’ve got a simple sore throat or something and need a strep test, a nurse practitioner or a physician assistant can take care of that. You don’t need a doctor. A doctor would be operating beneath the top of their license to give you that treatment, and this idea can and should extend to communications too.
It doesn’t today, but it could and it should. Here’s one way to think about it. Are you skilled and able to write a newsletter story when you’re a senior director? Yes, of course, but you’re not operating at the top of your license when you do that. It’s not a good use of your time. And if you want another analogy in the corporate world, you don’t expect your CFO to run payroll.
You don’t expect your CHRO to sit in on individual performance improvement plan conversations. So why is it expected in communications that you can and should do it all? You already know my answer. We expect it of ourselves. We allow others to expect it of us and internalize that. Sometimes we get told that we’re going to do it, and we then let it become normal.
Now, I will give you the out that some of you don’t have the authority to push back, but first, ask yourself, have you tried to push back? Have you tried a different way of pushing back? Have you tried to gain more authority as a resolution? And I don’t mean changing reporting structure every time. You can increase authority through influence.
Knowing Everything Isn’t the Same as Leading Everything
Again, I’ve done it, and I’ve helped others do it, too. And look, I used to be one of those people who believed I needed to know how to do every single thing when it came to communications, that I needed to just roll up my sleeves and get it done. I took pride in telling my team I wouldn’t ask them to do anything that I didn’t know how to do myself when it came to comms.
If they were tasked with something, probably from me, then I knew how to do it and I knew how to teach it to them. I will say my cross-functional comms expertise, you know, public relations, public affairs, internal communications, executive communications, crisis communications, I became an expert in all of it, and that has helped my career to where I am today.
I don’t regret it. It’s helped me advise others at this high level. I wouldn’t shy away from that path, but I also don’t think that you need to know how to do everything to manage it. Because I also know that I don’t know how to be a designer, but I can manage design. And I don’t need to know how to shoot videos to make multimedia part of a communication strategy.
What I need to know is I need to know enough to be dangerous, and by that, I mean enough to manage people who know it really well and to know enough about the area of expertise to know what works and what won’t, and to point out the parts that aren’t in their skill set that will help them grow in their career Okay, so what do you do with all of this?
How Communications Teams Can Change the Pattern
Well, the good news is you can see the pattern from inside at your company. You can see what I’m talking about if it’s experienced inside your company. You can even name it. Changing it, that’s different. Operating at the top of your license has to happen with the whole team, not just with you. Which requests are advising and which require execution?
Who takes which? What does the team say when something lands outside of your responsibility set without being seen as the department of no? How do we keep relationships while telling people things that they sometimes don’t want to hear? How do we decline work that we shouldn’t be doing at all? And in some cases, frankly, no one should be doing at the company at all, anywhere.
That’s what we do in the Communications Business Advisor™ Team Intensive. It’s a four-hour training, half day, usually when you’re doing an insight onsite meeting. It’s real scenarios pulled from your team’s actual work, worked through together so everyone leaves working from the same standard, the same language.
You have consistent understanding, consistent language, and a team-oriented approach that rallies you together. If you want to know where your team stands right now on this path to gaining more authority as a Communications Business Advisor™, then take the Communications Team Authority Index™. I developed it.
It’s a free diagnostic tool, and you can find it at taramcdonagh.com. It’s 10 questions. It’ll take five minutes. The link will be in the show notes. And if you want to talk about the team intensive that I mentioned just a minute ago, shoot me a message through my website. Again, the link is in the show notes.
If this episode hit a nerve for a different reason, maybe like you resonated with being the youngest at the table, afraid to be the department of no, deferring because the executive must know better, that’s the stuff people reach out to me about. They want to work with me as a thought partner for ongoing counsel.
I’ll push you on what’s happening in real time and challenge you on ways that you could approach these things in ways you might not be thinking about today, because you can’t see the label when you’re inside the jar.
The Takeaway
So here’s what I want you to take from this episode. Your doctor doesn’t do everything.
Your finance leader doesn’t do everything. Neither should you. Operate at the top of your license, normalize it, and keep advising, my friends. Always keep advising. Until next time.
Want More?
The Communications Team Authority Index™
Critical business advisors? Let's check.
Five minutes. Ten Questions. One number that tells you where your team stands.
Level Up Emails
Inbox boring? I have a cure for that.
Strategic thinking for communications leaders who are done being the best-kept secret in the company.
Raise the Tide Emails
Raise the Tide with us.
Get insights, advice, and honest perspective specifically for women in the field from women in the field—delivered right to your inbox.