Communications Business Advisor COLOR

Episode 52: Raise the Tide, 3 Years Later: For Women in Communications

Women leaders in Communications navigate the flaming tightrope of advocacy in a misunderstood and oversimplified profession every day. Tara shares how walking that tightrope becomes more secure, and how you can continue to advance your career, respect for your team and our profession, in this episode.

“Be more assertive.” “Soften your delivery.” “Speak up more.” “Listen more.”

For women leading Communications teams in-house, contradictory feedback is consistent and exhausting. And as you advance, you finally reach a place where no one understands your responsibilities, your challenges, and there is no one to advocate for you and your team anymore, aside from you. The realities of being a woman in a frequently misunderstood profession becomes harder, and you need something different to navigate it successfully. 

In this episode of the Communications Business Advisor™ Podcast, Tara McDonagh shares why she created Raise the Tide™’s flagship program, Surge, what she’s learned from three years of supporting women leaders working in-house in the Communications profession through this program, and what makes it so very different from traditional networking, community, coaching, and professional development programs. 

Tara takes you inside Raise the Tide’s Surge program, a small-group coaching, mentorship, executive development, and peer community for women working in-house in Communications at the Senior Manager through VP levels. She explains why the groups are intentionally small, how members support one another, and what it’s like to have Tara, an experienced Communications leader, in your corner.

She also shares the results women have achieved in the program, from multiple promotions for multiple women (sometimes multiple in a year for individual women), raises of 10 to 40 percent, expanded budgets, additional headcount, greater executive influence, and renewed love for this profession.

In this episode, you’ll hear:

  • How contradictory leadership feedback creates a double bind for women in Communications.
  • Why senior Communications leaders working in-house lack mentors who truly understand their work, and how that can stall their career.
  • How Raise the Tide Surge’s small, confidential peer groups work, and why. 
  • What Tara’s coaching, mentorship, goal-setting, and real-time support look like.
  • Results of Raise the Tide Surge, including promotions, increased compensation, additional headcount, greater authority, friendships, and reclaimed love for the profession
  • Why Raise the Tide Surge is designed specifically for in-house women in Communications, and how to request an invitation.

Raise the Tide™ Surge

Raise the Tide’s flagship program, Surge, is a 12-month coaching, mentorship, community, and professional/leadership development experience for women in-house in Communications at the Senior Manager, Director, Senior Director, and VP levels.

If you’re ready for support from women who understand your work and a mentor who’s been in your seat, learn more about Raise the Tide Surge, and request an invitation.

To learn more about the program, explore Raise the Tide™ Surge. You can also sign up for Raise the Tide™ emails for ongoing insights, resources, and updates for women in Communications. 

 

About Tara McDonagh

Tara McDonagh is a Communications Business Advisor™ activist, founder of Tara McDonagh Communications, Inc., and Founder of Raise the Tide™ for women in Communications. She advises Chief Communications Officers, Vice Presidents, and Senior Directors at Fortune 500 and other large organizations on advancing their function as critical business advisors. Recognized by the Public Relations Society of America (PRSA) in 2026 as an industry champion and thought leader, Tara helps Communications teams elevate their reputations as critical advisors while elevating our profession and the people in it.

Tara McDonagh Communications’ clients span industries including healthcare, pharmaceuticals, life sciences, automotive, manufacturing, food and beverage, financial services, and higher education. Tara McDonagh’s clients typically range from about $1 billion to more than $180 billion in annual revenue and from about 2,000 to more than 150,000 employees.

With nearly 30 years of experience leading communications at some of the nation’s largest, most complex, and most highly regulated brands, Tara’s counsel comes from experience across communications disciplines: public relations, public affairs, internal communications, executive communications, and crisis communications. She quite literally knows what it’s like to do the role and helps those she advises elevate their team’s expertise and their own reputations.

 

Resources:

 

Work with Tara: Learn more about working with Tara.
https://www.taramcdonagh.com

Communications Team Authority Index™: Take the ten-question, five-minute diagnostic that shows where your team really sits on the path to being viewed and treated as critical Communications Business Advisors™.
https://www.taramcdonagh.com/authority-index/

Raise the Tide™: Explore Raise the Tide™ and sign up for insights for women in Communications.
https://www.raisethetide.com

Newsletter: Get Tara’s newsletter on advancing as a Communications Business Advisor™, Level Up: Be Extra.
https://www.taramcdonagh.com/levelup/

This episode is sponsored by Raise the Tide™, a professional development ecosystem for women in communications, helping them grow, connect, and lead with confidence through mentorship, coaching, professional development, and community.

If you found this episode valuable, please rate and review. It helps more communicators find the show and strengthens our collective voice.

Until next time, keep advising. Always keep advising.

Help Elevate the Profession
Share this episode with your colleagues and communications network.

Email
LinkedIn
Threads
Reddit

Episode Transcript

Edited for readability. Speaker dialogue and substantive discussion are preserved.

Episode 52: Raise the Tide 3 Years Later: For Women in Communications

The Feedback Double Bind for Women in Communications

Tara McDonagh: You need better executive presence. Soften your delivery just a little bit. Stop saying sorry. Be more assertive. Be less abrasive. If you’re a woman in communications and you’ve been at this for a while, you could add three more to that list without even trying. I’ve heard every one of them myself, and the women that I work with in consulting and coaching, they tell me they hear them all the time too.

Tara McDonagh: Now, notice what these have in common. They’re about how you act, not what you deliver. They’re all about how you should, how you should, well, be essentially different than who you are. But what I almost never hear is the other kind of guidance, that kind of guidance that sounds a bit more like, “Here’s who has been where you’re going, and she can help you get there too,” or, “Here’s who will tell you what’s actually happening in that meeting.”

Tara McDonagh: That kind of guidance, though, it does exist. I built it. That’s how I know. Today, I’m gonna talk to you a little bit more about why it exists, what it’s like inside, and what you get from me, and what changes for the women who do it

Tara McDonagh: Hey, it’s Tara, and welcome back to the Communications Business Advisor. This one’s for a specific group of you. If you’re a woman working in-house in communications somewhere between senior manager and VP, this episode has your name on it. And if that’s not you, stay anyway.

Tara McDonagh: You probably know someone who fits, and by the end of this you’ll know exactly what to send her. Now, to be clear about what I’m talking about today, this is specifically the Raise the Tide™ SURGE program I’m gonna talk about. It’s the flagship proven program for women in-house in communications at the emerging leader and leader levels, so like senior manager to VP, two different groups.

Tara McDonagh: There are other Raise the Tide™ programs that I offer, but I won’t cover those today. Today we’re talking about the one that’s been around for a good bit. A heads-up before we start on that. I’m gonna tell you everything about how it works, because I want you to be able to decide if this is for you, for yourself.

Tara McDonagh: And I’m also gonna tell you that not everyone who asks to get in gets in. It’s important that I be picky on purpose, and I’ll explain why. So let’s start with the problem because it’s bigger than most of us see or admit. First, the feedback. It’s almost always designed to be helpful. Nobody is giving you feedback to make things harder for you.

Tara McDonagh: They want you to succeed. But well-intentioned and accurate are not the same thing, and well-intentioned and useful definitely aren’t the same thing either. One person in your 360 says you need to speak up more, and another says that you need to listen more. Which is it? Right? One says you’re abrasive.

Tara McDonagh: Another says that they want to hear your strong counsel delivered with confidence. One says that you’re cold and you need to be more approachable, and another says that you’re warm and likable, but you need to be more buttoned up. You know, quote, unquote, “buttoned up.” That all has a name. It’s called the double bind, and it’s actually worse than a double standard because with a double standard, you might have to work harder, but you can still reach the goal.

Tara McDonagh: It’s unfair, but still achievable. With a double bind, there’s actually no right way to win. You’re darned if you do and darned if you don’t. You know, this is a clean podcast, so I’m keeping it clean from what I actually wanna say there. But here’s the trap with that. We’re all taught to take feedback that’s offered.

Tara McDonagh: You know, don’t be defensive. We’re taught that from a very early age, right? And so if it shows up as defensiveness at work, then that’s a terrible thing to be, right? So we’re taught to take the feedback that’s offered. Somewhere in there, we also learn to take it as gospel. Someone said it, so it must be accurate, so I need to act on it.

Tara McDonagh: Do not get defensive. So you hear be more assertive and you work on it. You challenge yourself. You rethink your approach. Maybe you tone down yourself a little bit as a result, and then you’re told you aren’t advising enough at the critical moments. You’ve overcorrected, and then it ends up worse because you did what they asked, but it didn’t work.

Tara McDonagh: And now you’re questioning yourself 8,000 times and wondering what the, quote-unquote, “right way to do this” even is. Well, what if not all feedback is useful? Well-intentioned, yes. Useful, no. I’m not saying dismiss everything you hear. God knows there are plenty of junior communicators out there who need to hear about taking initiative, being proactive, solving problems instead of bringing problems, and how critical relationships are to all of this.

Tara McDonagh: But I’m not talking about that stage of your career. To be clear, this is not that stage. I’m talking about the phase where you’re a leader who manages a comms department or a senior leader in this field with a team to manage and a big remit with a boss who doesn’t really know comms. That place where you’re suddenly in a position where you need to advocate for your department, yourself, and your team while you’re also a woman.

Tara McDonagh: And right or wrong… Well, no, it’s actually always wrong. It’s always wrong, but it’s still true. When women advocate, it’s received differently than when men do, and it doesn’t matter if the person on the receiving end is a man or a woman. In one study, women were 11 times more likely than men to be called abrasive in feedback.

Tara McDonagh: 11 times. In another, where the researcher evaluated performance evaluations, so, like, the performance feedback that we get across various companies, women were called abrasive 17 different times among 13 different women But that word never came up, not once, with men’s performance evaluations. Not once.

Tara McDonagh: Yeah. So can we admit that advocacy as a woman hits different, as the kids say? If you don’t buy that, the rest of this episode is probably not for you. But if you do buy it, keep listening. So moving on. Right around that senior manager to VP level, the feedback we get moves towards delivery and presence and away from substance, away from the things, right?

Tara McDonagh: And that makes some sense because at that level, advocacy and relationships and presence, those do matter at that leadership level. But when you’re in a misunderstood and oversimplified field like ours, and you feel like you need to advocate for it so the company can actually see the breadth of what your team can offer, it comes off as abrasive, dun, particularly if you’re a woman.

Why Communications Leaders Need a Different Kind of Support

Tara McDonagh: Here’s the bigger problem, though. Beyond the feedback that we get that is at best confusing and at worst damaging, we hit a point where the other kind of insight dries up, the kind that’s actually designed to grow your career, because that kind of insight just doesn’t exist in your company once you get far enough. At that point, you’re it.

Tara McDonagh: There’s no one else in the building who knows what it’s like to be in this field and to be a woman. You’re pointed towards people to model yourself after, like the CHRO or the CFO or some other woman in a leadership role. But they work in functions where people actually know enough to know that those functions are critical and they belong in the C-suite, and even if they don’t fully know what’s involved with all of the pieces of it.

Tara McDonagh: A woman CFO’s expertise doesn’t get questioned the same way that yours does. A woman finance director’s expertise doesn’t get questioned the same way a comms director’s does. People in the meeting defer to a head of finance, but they will question the comms leader because they don’t give that same kind of deference and knowledge.

Tara McDonagh: They think that they do know comms. They’re just wrong. So then you might ask yourself, “Who’s advocating with me or for me?” And the answer is, for most of you, no one. There’s no one in the building who sees the whole picture of what your job is, and worse, some of them oversimplify it to the detriment of your future.

Tara McDonagh: Rather than recognize that comms deserves more respect, they try to broaden your role. You’ll get pushed towards chief of staff roles or asked to manage more beyond comms because just doing comms, quote-unquote, limits your potential. Now, that one kind of makes me both rage-y and laugh because if there was ever a phrase, I mean, tell me you don’t know the impact of comms without telling me you don’t know the impact of comms when you say that kind of thing So with all of this, you do what high performers do, what you have always done.

Tara McDonagh: You figure it out alone, and you stay stuck. And then you start to wonder if it’s you. Am I no longer good at this? No, I am good at this, right? You’ll convince yourself. But wait, am I not good enough for this level? Am I crazy or are they crazy? You’re not crazy. Our field is one of the most oversimplified, misunderstood functions in any business.

Tara McDonagh: Everyone thinks that it’s, you know, just writing, just communicating. Everyone communicates, right? Very few people understand it. Other functions get misunderstood, too. But the difference is that with comms, people think that they do know what it is. Again, they’re just wrong. So what do you do when you’re at the top of your fields in your company and you don’t know who to learn from next?

Tara McDonagh: You can’t tell whether what you’re hearing is relevant or if it should be thrown out. And you’re constantly made to wonder if it’s you, or just how comms is treated, or just how women are treated, or because you look young or. More ors, right? You need a place to ask the vulnerable questions. Not the kind that you ask a group of 50 people you kinda know, or the kind that you get in a learning-focused forum where you’re getting the latest tips on how to use AI.

Tara McDonagh: Which by the way, those exist and they’re great, and I even offer one of them. But that kind of support just isn’t the thing that you need at this particular stage. This is the kind of question that you like to ask your best friend, right? Someone that you’re that comfortable with. But a best friend who actually knows your work. All of this can make you fall out of love with this field.

Changing Systems, Not Women

Tara McDonagh: It can drive you to an entirely different career or make you lose sight of who you are in the middle of well-intentioned, poorly delivered feedback designed to change who you are. So what do you do about it? What do you do about the double bind for women? Well, you change systems, not women. You change the perceptions around you, not yourself.

Tara McDonagh: And I don’t mean some mass overthrow of corporations, and I’m not telling you men are bad and women are good. That is not it, and it is not what works. What I mean is accepting that you do not need to change who you are in order to lead, because you don’t. I didn’t build this on a hunch. I have a degree in communications, including communication theory, and I also studied gender differences in human communication back at university, and I never stopped reading the research ever since.

Tara McDonagh: Add nearly 30 years in this field as a corporate communications leader, and I could see what was missing for women in this field and how to fix it. And this program, it has been around long enough now that it is no longer a gamble. It is proven. I built something for women who want to stay in corporate, stay in love with communications, or reclaim their love for it, be seen by people who actually get it and keep growing their careers, incomes.

Tara McDonagh: A place where the answer isn’t be different. It’s here are the right people around you, and here’s the guidance that you need to go further without burning yourself out or changing who you are in the process, shaking your confidence all along the way with each piece of feedback that’s just incorrect.

Inside Raise the Tide™ SURGE

Tara McDonagh: Okay, so what does this look like on just like an everyday Tuesday? Glad you didn’t ask. I’m gonna give it to you anyway. Picture a small group of women at your level, up to eight of them max, same level of responsibility, different industries, different companies. Nobody’s a competitor. Nobody’s your boss’s friend.

Tara McDonagh: Nobody’s your staff member. Nobody works in a different field. We get on a live video session for about 90 minutes once a month. I’m the coach and the mentor in those sessions. I set the pace, the content of the conversations, and the format for every single one of them. Now, you’d think that 90 minutes feels long.

Tara McDonagh: I know how 90 minutes feels in a meeting when you’re in corporate, but this flies. This meeting, it flies. And I don’t give you an agenda to prepare for. There’s no homework to complete before you show up, and by the way, that is by design. I do it on purpose for a few reasons that you would not guess.

Tara McDonagh: There is a method behind each of my decisions from why we don’t have an agenda to why we start every meeting with a win, and they are never the reasons that you think. You might think that there’s some easy thinking behind these things, but they’re actually a little bit more complex. They’re part of the secret sauce that actually makes Raise the Tide™ work.

Tara McDonagh: Proven, and by proven, I mean with results to brag about. I’ll get to those in a minute. You walk into those meetings with whatever’s on your plate, you know, the thing you can’t say out loud at work, and then you say it. And what happens next is the reason that people stay. Somebody says, “Oh, I’ve been there.

Tara McDonagh: Here’s what I did. Maybe that’ll help.” Somebody else says, “Wait, say more about that situation with your boss or your direct report or that marketing guy who’s constantly undermining your work in a sneaky way.” And what’s said in the group stays in the group, and that’s the whole deal. You cannot be candid anywhere that isn’t safe.

Tara McDonagh: So safe comes first. Confidentiality is taken so seriously that I don’t even share who’s in the group until you’re vetted, and then I might link you up with a member who’s happy to tell you what it’s like to be in the crew before you make the final decision, but not until then. Now, beyond the monthly calls, there’s so much more.

Tara McDonagh: Between sessions, you’re not on your own. I give you a private place with just your crew to share your wins, ask questions, vent, share the thing that someone said that you then implemented inside your team that made a massive difference. We do learning amongst one another, and then there’s the retreat.

Tara McDonagh: Now, people hear a ton about this one, and they ask a lot of questions. The enthusiasm for this is high when you show up, when you leave. It is high about the retreat, and it is for good reason. Once a year, we gather together in person for two days. That’s where the connection from all of those video calls turns into something that lasts way past the year itself.

Tara McDonagh: These people, they become your genuine friends. There’s lots of laughter, tons of learning from one another, and always some tears. I joke that if there aren’t tears, it wasn’t really a retreat, but it actually shouldn’t be a joke because it actually happens every single time, and that’s how you know it’s a real and powerful experience because you’re not gonna cry in front of that colleague that you met at a PRSA conference or an IABC workshop.

Tara McDonagh: You’re not going to share your fears or admit what you don’t know in some broad program designed to teach you some new comms tips on how to deploy AI or who to know in the media or something like that. You’ll only be vulnerable enough to cry with a handful of people you trust, and the retreat is where it happens.

Tara McDonagh: It’s also included in the program The membership in Raise the Tide™, it runs 12 months from the day you join. Now, I know what some of you are thinking because I hear it a lot. “This sounds awesome, Tara, but I’m already overwhelmed. Will I even have enough time? I worry I won’t be able to give the group enough.

Tara McDonagh: I won’t be able to get enough.” Here’s my answer to that. Be there for what you can. This isn’t one more obligation, and it won’t feel like it’s one. It’s a place for you to seek something for you, a place and a time and space and people that are yours. If you miss a call or you can’t get on the app to respond to a pal for a couple of weeks, no worries.

Tara McDonagh: We provide a lot in this program, but pressure is not something we provide. Showing up for each other doesn’t mean perfect attendance. It means that when you’re there, you’re really there, and that’s what counts, and that’s what people remember. Here’s the part that I really wanna make sure you hear because if you ask members what they’d never give up in the program, most will tell you it’s access to me, and that is really uncomfortable for me to say, but I’m gonna coach myself through it and say it anyway because I’ve asked all of them, “What’s the one thing that you could not do without in this program?”

Coaching and Mentorship from Tara

Tara McDonagh: And they all talk about access to me. So here it is, my coaching, my mentorship, and how I work with them. Honestly, it took me a long time to talk about that as a key factor because I love to defer to the power of the group and the experience of the connection, all of which are very true, but after I heard it again and again, and I was asked, frankly, straight out, why don’t I talk about it more, I realized I need to be clear about that part.

Tara McDonagh: So let’s talk about what it means. I’ve sat in your seat. I have been the leader of communications at large companies, PR, internal comms, public affairs, executive comms, crisis comms. I have led it. So when I tell you what’s actually going on in a situation, it’s not theory, and that’s the mentorship part. I tell you what’s really happening, then I coach you through deciding what you wanna do about it.

Tara McDonagh: Not what I would do, what you wanna do. That’s the coaching part. Both happen in action in the same conversation. How efficient. Awesome, right? Access to me isn’t limited to the monthly call, though. So when you’re in the pickup line at school, or you’re waiting while they load your groceries into the trunk, because honestly, like, who ever wants to go to the grocery store ever again?

Tara McDonagh: Who has the time for that? Well, anyway, during those moments, you can tell me individually, one-on-one, or tell us, meaning your crew, what’s going on. Get real-time guidance. Celebrate a win. Talk about something that went into getting that win. I mean, when you share that, you’re talking about it with people who actually get what getting that accomplishment means, how hard it was.

Tara McDonagh: We get it. Or maybe you just wanna check if you’re crazy on something, or if you’re being gaslit again. You don’t have to wait to schedule a specific call about something that might be solved with a three-minute voice message exchange. That’s the power of the in-between sessions, the ongoing connection.

Tara McDonagh: And then there’s what I call the break glass call, you know, ’cause, like, in case of emergency, break the glass. It’s for the moment where something big happens. You’re tempted to go cry in the bathroom at work, which an actual CCO that I interviewed said that she did that. And so I’ve done that, too, and I can say that is for sure something that happens that you might resonate with.

Tara McDonagh: When you’re tempted to go cry in the bathroom at work, or you’re so angry that you think you might scream at someone, you need to get through it, and you need to talk with someone who gets it, someone who can actually help instead of telling you how to make it better without knowing anything about it, like my husband would.

Tara McDonagh: Probably your spouse, too. Raise the Tide™ has saved many marriages, by the way. I mean, I kid on that, but, like, also not because when you have people who get it, you come to them instead of going to someone who can’t actually help however much they want to. And it alleviates a ton of frustration on that front.

Tara McDonagh: You also get one-on-one career goal setting with me. So where do you wanna be? What’s in the way? What are we gonna do about it? You might not even know what that is right now. Clarity might be the thing that you wanna gain, and then that becomes the goal. And through a few sessions throughout the year with just me and you one on one, we regroup on those goals and decide whether to dig a layer deeper, swap one out because you already hit it, or add something new.

Tara McDonagh: Then there’s the practical stuff. If you need your company to sponsor you for this, I help you prepare for that ask. That’s what you get from me in your corner with all the knowledge and insight that I bring to the conversation. Now, what happens to women inside Raise the Tide™? Here’s what I can tell you because I have seen it happen and I have the voice messages, texts, the formal testimonials telling me the same story over and over.

What Changes for SURGE Members

Tara McDonagh: Promotions across level and industry. One member told me that she was professionally sad when she started. You know, after a reorg, she had felt like no one knew her anymore. So we created a plan to change that. And since joining Raise the Tide™, she’s been promoted four times, three of them in one year, and she’s credited Raise the Tide™ for helping her make that happen.

Tara McDonagh: I believe her exact words were something like she’s convinced it wouldn’t have happened without Raise the Tide™. But she’s also told me that the promotions are the smaller part of what the group does for her, which is a pretty bold statement. She’s still a member three years later. Next big thing that happens, raises anywhere from ten to 40%, including during layoffs and including during company-wide pay freezes.

Tara McDonagh: After women have been told that the money just wasn’t there, they still get the money and budget. In one case, a leader’s budget doubled after years of being told no over and over and smaller teams and cut the teams and cut the teams more. That changed. Headcount. That’s another thing that increases after being told it wouldn’t happen, after experiencing consistent cuts.

Tara McDonagh: In one case, a team size more than doubled. As you’ve heard from me before, this field is part art and part science. We don’t need to apologize for the art, we just need to provide the science and share some of the art. So I told you about the things about multiple promotions, some promotions multiple times in a year.

Tara McDonagh: There’s actually two of those stories, multiple promotions in a year for two members. Additional headcount, additional budget, all things that can be counted, right? But here’s the art of it. Here’s the stuff you can’t really put numbers on. First, clarity. So many times I am told that women have either lost their love for their field, they just wanna think about how to get out of it, or they’re confused about what’s next, or they’re struggling with how to grow without dedicating even more of their personal time to their careers.

Tara McDonagh: What they’re really looking for is to reclaim joy in this field, the thing that they used to love about it, and to find clarity for what’s next for them. That’s hard to put numbers on, but that clarity happens over and over. Next, friendships. How many times have you tried to explain what you’re dealing with at work to your husband, you know, your spouse, your best friend, and gotten a blank stare or a, “Oh, I’m sorry, that must be hard,” or worse, advice on how to fix it?

Tara McDonagh: And if they’re like my husband, they try to fix it, and I wanna stab him when he does that. I hear from women over and over that this is universal, but here’s the thing. Know your audience, right? Your spouse, your best friend, they do not get it. They cannot get it. But women at your level in your field, they get it.

Tara McDonagh: And when you can bond over that shared understanding while also cheering them on when they have their next baby, or find a next job, or buy a house, or be thoughtful and caring and there for them when they lose a parent or get a divorce, that’s the kind of connection that you cannot put numbers on that happens through the way that Raise the Tide™ works and that lasts well beyond the time in the program.

Tara McDonagh: And finally, more authority. Being pulled into decisions earlier instead of being handed the decision after it’s made. There’s a line every woman in this group has heard me say, “We don’t take the first no as the final no.” You know, you hear no to the staffing model, no to the seat at the executive meeting, no to a raise that matches your expanded role.

Turning a No into a Yes

Tara McDonagh: In Raise the Tide™, we figure out how to turn a no into a yes. No is the door opener. Now, I want to tell you about one of these. A Raise the Tide™ member wanted her company to sponsor her for this program. This happened very recently, but first some context on it. In some cases, Raise the Tide™ is just part of the comms budget because you’re gaining perspective from other people in your shoes on things that make comms at your company better.

Tara McDonagh: We talk about real-world stuff that is actually happening in the moment and how you can learn from what other comms leaders are doing. So it fits into comms budget. In other cases, women might choose to self-fund the program as an investment in themselves. And also, in other cases, women decide that they want their company to sponsor them, but they don’t have control over the budget and they need to figure out how to make the ask.

Tara McDonagh: So in this particular situation, she needed to advocate for company sponsorship. That was her path that she was choosing, and that meant asking the CEO in this particular case. In a cost-cutting year, where asking for anything felt like a huge reputational risk. And look, I get it. Asking for an investment when the company is cutting everywhere can feel like you’ll be seen as tone deaf to the moment, right when you’re building credibility for yourself as a leader and for your department.

Tara McDonagh: That I understand completely. But it doesn’t mean don’t go ask. It means how you ask is critical, and when can definitely be a factor, too. But some women, they’ll just never find the ideal when. When is often something that you just wait for and wait for and wait for and then never end up doing. In this particular case, I spoke with her about a year ago, and nothing changed in that time except her decision to make the ask.

Tara McDonagh: She was really nervous about it, so much so that it took months before she went and made the ask. Circumstances at the company didn’t change in this time. The cost cutting, that actually got more severe. But she went to him and she made the ask anyway. I gave her everything she needed to prepare, phrasing and documents, and that included a different way to look at the risk, because what I know about all of you is that asking isn’t the risk that you think it is Asking wasn’t the risk she thought it was, even if the answer comes back as no.

Tara McDonagh: But guess what? He said yes. And that’s not unusual. The fear of asking, very typical. So is getting the yes. The women who get no, it’s never, “How dare you ask? How dare you?” No, it’s never even a subtle thought that goes unsaid like, you know, “She’s tone deaf to the moment.” We have years of data at this point.

Tara McDonagh: A no means not yet, but I buy in on the value. In one case, a member went through three different routes to find the funding. In her words, “No isn’t in my vocabulary.” And then she got the funding. Think about that. The thing that you’ve been avoiding because you assumed it would cost you, that’s a conversation that usually goes a lot better than the one that’s going on in your head.

Tara McDonagh: We’re trained to think about risk and call it out, right? Crisis preparedness, scenario planning. We are experts at this. We have a superpower. So much so that the benefit can take a backseat even when it outweighs the risk. And then there’s one more change that doesn’t show up on a resume or a paycheck that I have to share with you.

Tara McDonagh: When you’re not spending all of your energy proving yourself, you get your head and your heart back. You think strategically again. You remember why you loved this field in the first place. That’s the part that members tell me about universally.

Who Raise the Tide™ SURGE Is For

Tara McDonagh: So who is this for? Well, every woman has a one-on-one conversation with me before she enters the program, and I read every request to join myself.

Tara McDonagh: Not everyone gets in, and I’m not being some jerky gatekeeper about it. The group only works when the right women are in it, and I take that very seriously. Crew members still joke that they haven’t cracked my criteria. Yes, it is a secret sauce. I won’t share all of that criteria here in case someone tries to game the system here, but I will share the first bar to clear.

Tara McDonagh: You have to work in-house. That might include universities, hospitals, nonprofits, complex big nonprofits, and obviously big corporations. You also carry real communications responsibility, whether that’s PR, internal comms, executive comms, public affairs, or related areas, or all of the above. Now, typically, that starts at senior manager and it goes up to VP, and we put those levels and what’s in between into two different groups based on scope and authority.

Tara McDonagh: Another criteria is that you have to be curious about getting better, and you actually have to want to help the woman next to you. And this is not criteria, but it’s kind of an interesting side effect. one side effect of all of this is that we attract ambitious overachievers. Tends to be a common denominator.

Tara McDonagh: Now, whether you’re type A or type B, doesn’t matter, but ambitious overachievers unite in this program because we all take our career growth seriously, though we’re feeling a little stuck and frustrated. And since I’m being specific, I’ll also tell you who this is not for. If you’re consulting or on the agency side, this is not your group.

Tara McDonagh: The issues and challenges that you face are very different from those of someone leading communications inside a company, and the whole point is a group of women who live the same days as you do. There’s a different program designed for you on the consulting side, and it’s called Voyagers. So you can check that out.

Tara McDonagh: If you’re below the senior manager level, this isn’t your group either, and that’s for the same reason. The challenges that you face are very different. There are two groups here in Raise the Tide™, the SURGE program. One is for senior managers and directors and one for senior directors and VPs. The challenges at those levels are different from each other too, so we focus on peer groups that actually make sense And if you want a webinar or a playbook handed to you so you can go at it alone and figure it out, this probably isn’t your group.

Tara McDonagh: That’s okay, too. There are programs for people who want that. I even have one of them. This just isn’t it. You can’t get the kind of impact I’m talking about with a program like that. And if you’d rather listen in than say anything real, or you’d rather not hear what I actually think, you’d rather not get to know the women in your crew, this is definitely not for you.

Tara McDonagh: But if you’re in-house at the right level, you wanna learn from people and with people, gain clarity, get mentorship and coaching, and unlock what the next level of your career looks like, that is what this is for. The group stays small, eight women in each group, and I review requests at the start of every month.

Common Questions About Joining

Tara McDonagh: If you’re a fit at that initial bar, if you meet that initial bar, I’ll invite you to a conversation as a next step. And now I also know the what-ifs that you all worry and wonder about. Again, scenario planners unite. You know, what if I get laid off during the year? Yeah. Then we make a plan together. It’s happened, and in both cases where this happened and the women were self-pay, they decided to stick with the program and use it to help them find the next role.

Tara McDonagh: Okay, what happens if life happens? Because it’s a year, it will. Life doesn’t politely wait for you to finish investing in your career. That’s why there’s no pressure, no attendance, no scorecard. But also, like, pregnancy, that’s a very real thing, right? We offer maternity leave in this program, so the time that you’re off of work, you can take off from the program too and pick right back up when you get back.

Tara McDonagh: And then the last question I get a lot, “What if I can’t get it funded?” Well, before you jump there, most women think about that question after they’ve already decided that the answer’s gonna be no. Well, think about that woman that I just told you about before you decide how your company will respond.

How to Request an Invitation

Tara McDonagh: And if you wanna be considered, this all sounds good to you start by requesting an invitation. Go to taramcdonagh.com and look for Raise the Tide™ SURGE. You’re looking for Surge specifically, or use the link in the show notes. It’s a short form, a few questions, and if it looks like a fit, we’ll talk as a next step So summing this all up, the TLDR version or what?

The Takeaway

Tara McDonagh: too long, didn’t listen. I guess that’s what it would be. Why it exists. Because the work gets bigger and the people around you get fewer and be different isn’t help. It harms. What it’s like. A small group, eight women max, a live online session once a month with no prep, a place to say the real thing and connect with people who get it in between calls, a retreat once a year.

Tara McDonagh: What you get from me. My coaching, my mentorship, real-time access, a break glass call for the really tough day that happens, goals that you actually follow up on, and a year of it with no pressure. What changes. Promotions, raises, budget increases, headcount increases, a seat at the table earlier, and your head and your heart back in this field.

Tara McDonagh: I started Raise the Tide™ so women in this field wouldn’t have to choose between a career that they love and a life that they want. That’s still the whole point. If any of this sounded like you, request your invitation. If it sounded like a friend, send her the episode.

Tara McDonagh: keep advising, my friends. Always keep advising.

Want More?

The Communications Team Authority Index™

Critical business advisors? Let's check.

Five minutes. Ten Questions. One number that tells you where your team stands.

Level Up Emails

Inbox boring? I have a cure for that.

Strategic thinking for communications leaders who are done being the best-kept secret in the company.  

Raise the Tide Emails

Raise the Tide with us.

Get insights, advice, and honest perspective  specifically for women in the field from women in the field—delivered right to your inbox.